Reading ➸ Evolution and the Fall Author James K.A. Smith – Ovirt.info
I wanted so much to love this book I have a lot of respect for the Colossian Forum, assembling a group philosophers to write on the doctrine of the fall in light of evolution science From the outset, the authors establish their two main parameters 1 Evolutionary science strongly shows that homo sapiens did not arrive from a single pair, but 2000 10000 individuals And 2 Religion has much to offer to the faith science dialogue, must stand on its non negotiables, and is in no way second fiddle to science The book is broken into four sections Mapping the Questions, Biblical Studies and Theological Implications, Beyond Origins Cultural Implications, and Reimagining the Conversation Faithful Ways Forward Across these sections are 10 chapters, each written by a different contributer The lack of scientists is disappointing 1 Darrel Falk to 9 philosophers Some chapters are of course better than others While there is much virtue in beginning this conversation, the book suffers two weaknesses 1 It struggles with consistency Some contributors write their chapters as if they re a plug for their own work, rather than seeking to integrate the chapter into the narrative whole More problematic, chapters 45 make the case that A smorgasbord of essays from various authors touching on subjects of Bible interpretation, original sin and evolution, and advice on approaching the whole subject humbly The prologue and the final essay were, in my opinion, the best pieces If the entire book was as clear and tangible as those sections, then maybe I d rate it 5 stars This was a nice piece of literature to add to the incre This is one of those books that might have come off better if they didn t claim a specific focus The editors describe this book as an interdisciplinary look at how the doctrines of the fall and original sin are impacted if there is no historical Adam and Eve Unfortunately, that is a poor description of the project as a whole Of the ten essays only three or four of them really focus on that question The rest focus on topics without any obvious connection such as poetry and politics Granted, these essays are still interesting, I was nevertheless left wondering why they were included in this volume If the editors had framed the book with a broader goal, it would have been fine But as stated, I never felt like the question of how to understand the fall of man and original sin in light of evolutionary theory was suc A thoroughly interesting book for those wanting talking points on the conversation between evolution, the fall, and Christianity At times, I forgot the driving factor behind the book was the conversation between evolution and Christianity, and thought it to be a collection of essays about the human condition Certainly worth reading, if you are interested in better understanding our con The introduction, Chapter 1 Discussing the evidence for evolution , and James K.A Smiths essay are worth the price of the book Those sections are very well done Those essays provide the best discussions of the topic set out at the start of the book Some of the other sections are The chapter by Middleton which reads the story of the fall attentive to evolution is excellent and precisely what we need of strong exegesis and orthodox theology with an appreciation of what scientific knowledge may add to the story I hi As an anthology of essays, the writing is uneven By the time I got to the end, I wasn t sure what the goal of the book was On the way there, my thinking was challenged and I was brought up to date on some of the findings of the scientific community regarding the origin of humanity. What Does It Mean For The Christian Doctrine Of The Fall If There Was No Historical Adam If Humanity Emerged From Nonhuman Primates As Genetic, Biological, And Archaeological Evidence Seems To Suggest Then What Are The Implications For A Christian Understanding Of Human Origins, Including The Origin Of Sin Evolution And The Fall Gathers A Multidisciplinary, Ecumenical Team Of Scholars To Address These Difficult Questions And Others Like Them From The Perspectives Of Biology, Theology, History, Scripture, Philosophy, And PoliticsCONTRIBUTORS William T Cavanaugh Celia Deane Drummond Darrel R Falk Joel B Green Michael Gulker Peter Harrison J Richard Middleton Aaron Riches James K A Smith Brent Waters Norman Wirzba Some very strong individual essays here I most enjoyed the introduction, as well as the offerings of Riches, Wirzba, and Harrison but as a collection Evolution and the Fall struggles to create much continuity with the ideas it presents. The book is alright, but most essays in the book fail to address the question at hand Instead, they follow a million rabbit trails tangential to the question.